Sinn Fein’s anti-Treaty leaflet quotes three economists
(Karl Whelan, Colm McCarthy and Seamus Coffey) to bolster advocating a No
vote.
All three are in favour of the Treaty.
KARL WHELAN QUOTE
From the Sinn Fein
leaflet:
“…the economics of
this treaty are pretty terrible…”
KARL WHELAN, PROFESSOR OF ECONOMICS, UCD
What they don’t quote
is that he went on to say:
“On balance, the
arguments favour Ireland signing up to it.”
COLM MCCARTHY QUOTE
From the Sinn Fein
leaflet:
“As an exercise in addressing the Eurozone’s twin banking
and sovereign debt crises, the fiscal compact makes no worthwhile
contribution.”
COLM MCCARTHY, SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS, UCD
What they don’t quote:
Articles written by Colm McCarthy in recent weeks advocating
a Yes vote include the following:
“Voting No is a leap in the dark that we can't afford”,
Colm McCarthy, 1 April 2012. Irish Independent article
–headline.
“A Yes vote is the correct response, unavoidable and in the country's best interests”
Colm McCarthy, 18 February 2012, Irish Independent
article -headline.
SEAMUS COFFEY QUOTE
From the Sinn Fein
leaflet:
“Had the fiscal compact been in place since 1999 it could
not and would not have prevented the crisis in Ireland.”
SEAMUS COFFEY, SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS, UCC
What they don’t
quote:
“All in all there
is little to be gained from rejecting the Treaty.”
Seamus Coffey , on his blog, on 15 March 2012,